Advance Auto Parts vs. Monro: Two Auto Service Stocks at a Crossroads

"We returned to full year positive comparable sales growth following three years of negative results and expanded adjusted operating income margin by over 200-basis points. AAP's Q4 FY2025 performance demonstrates the company's successful turnaround strategy, marking a significant milestone after an extended period of declining comparable store sales and margin compression."

"Monro's Q3 FY2026 results reveal a company grinding forward despite revenue headwinds. While overall revenue fell 4% year-over-year to $293.39 million, operating income surged 86% to $18.57 million, marking the fourth consecutive quarter of positive comparable store sales with tires up 5% and front-end services up 7%, demonstrating operational improvement."

"AAP's restructuring is deeper and better funded with the company closing 522 stores in FY2025 while maintaining roughly $3.1 billion in cash, providing management substantial room to execute a multiyear fix. FY2026 guidance calls for adjusted operating margin of 3.8% to 4.5% and adjusted EPS of $2.40 to $3.10, representing a credible roadmap forward."

"Monro's balance sheet is far tighter with only $4.9 million in cash, leaving almost no margin for error. The company leaned on $13.53 million in real estate gains from closed stores to boost Q3 results, a one-time lever that cannot repeat, highlighting the precarious nature of its financial position."

Advance Auto Parts and Monro, both auto aftermarket companies, reported earnings reflecting recovery from years of negative comparable sales. AAP achieved +1.1% comparable store sales growth in Q4 FY2025 after three years of declines, expanding operating margins by over 200 basis points across 5,114 locations. Monro reported Q3 FY2026 revenue decline of 4% but achieved 86% operating income growth and four consecutive quarters of positive comps, with tires up 5% and front-end services up 7%. However, their financial positions diverge significantly: AAP maintains $3.1 billion in cash with credible FY2026 guidance of 3.8%-4.5% adjusted operating margins, while Monro operates with only $4.9 million cash and relied on $13.53 million in real estate gains to boost results.

Read at 24/7 Wall St.