57 Years Later, The 'Dune 3' Trailer Changes The Books In Two Massive Ways

"For longtime fans of Frank Herbert's original six novels, this statement, if taken at face value, sounds shocking. After spending two entire movies adapting the first 1965 novel, will the third installment somehow cram books two through six into one movie, including roughly 5,000 years of future history? The short answer is no. Dune: Part Three, based on the newly released character posters and just-released teaser trailer, is an adaptation of the second novel, 1969's Dune Messiah."

"The Dune 3 trailer differs from what we would expect of a straightforward adaptation of Messiah in several ways. First of all, a huge portion of this trailer focuses on the specifics of Paul's holy war across the galaxy, which happens mostly off-stage in between Dune and Dune Messiah. In other words, Dune 3 is clearly showing us things that don't happen in the books in real-time."

"Also, the timeline of Dune 3 is all over the place. The trailer shows us Alia (Anya Taylor-Joy) as a full-grown adult, which doesn't happen until Children of Dune. This complicates an existing continuity head-scratcher created by Dune: Part Two; Alia wasn't even born in that movie, but in Dune: Part Three, she's grown up."

Dune: Part Three is marketed as "The Epic Conclusion" and adapts Frank Herbert's 1969 novel Dune Messiah, not books two through six as the marketing might suggest. The film deviates from straightforward adaptation by depicting Paul's galactic holy war, which occurs mostly off-stage in the original novel. The trailer reveals significant timeline expansions, showing adult Alia despite her absence in Dune: Part Two, suggesting substantial time passage within the film. This marketing approach as a trilogy conclusion differs from the source material, which continues through Children of Dune and beyond, raising questions about how extensively the filmmakers are altering the narrative structure and scope.

Read at Inverse