No, Matthew McConaughey, AI Actors Are Not Coming for Your Oscar

"It's the latest example of how we are being told everyone in Hollywood is using Gen AI to make movies, but evidence on the big and small screens is scant. Mostly it's been used (undetected and unpublicized) as a behind-the-scenes tool as some in Hollywood try to incorporate it in their normal processes of filmmaking, and the extremely rare times actual Gen AI image creation had driven a commercial project, such as the Darren Aronofsky-produced docuseries "On This Day... 1776" for YouTube, it has been roundly rejected and deemed unwatchable slop."

"In the void between the technology's promise and its current capabilities, we are left with the AI hype machine, fueled by trillions of dollars of investment and social media discourse about how every new "shocking" Gen AI clip marks "the end of Hollywood." There is this predetermined narrative of disruption, when all we have are wild predictions, 10-second social media clips, and any celebrity willing to pontificate on AI going viral."

"The problem is this discourse, both from the pro and anti-AI sides, is too often based on nonsense, and even those inside Hollywood's efforts to incorporate AI are laughing at us."

Matthew McConaughey recently predicted AI would infiltrate acting award categories within five years, exemplifying pervasive Hollywood discourse about artificial intelligence's imminent dominance in filmmaking. However, evidence contradicts this narrative. Generative AI has primarily functioned as an undetected backend tool in production workflows. The rare instances where AI-generated imagery drove commercial projects, such as the Darren Aronofsky docuseries "On This Day... 1776," faced widespread rejection. A significant gap exists between AI technology's promised potential and its actual capabilities. The current discourse, fueled by massive investment and viral social media clips, perpetuates a predetermined disruption narrative based largely on speculation, brief demonstrations, and celebrity commentary rather than substantive evidence of transformative change in the industry.

Read at IndieWire