Mental Health and Sickness Benefits: Lessons From History

"Mental health problems account for the majority of sickness benefit claims, with 80% of young people on benefits claiming for a mental or neurodevelopmental disorder. Politicians worry there is 'overdiagnosis' of mental health problems. Alan Milburn, who is leading the government's review into Young People and Work, warns of a 'social catastrophe' and of a 'generation destined for the scrapheap'."

"Smith claimed there is a 'pandemic' of mental illness that affects one in eight people, is clearly distinguishable from the mental health challenges we all experience and requires medical treatment. People don't just get better on their own, she said, as they might with an infectious disease. 'If you don't get treated, things get worse'."

"At best, psychiatric treatments reduce symptoms by a few points on dubious measurement scales in the short-term. There is no evidence that treatment effects translate into better real-world outcomes or long-term benefits. And rising prescriptions of antidepressants over the last few decades have been accompanied by rising ra"

The UK faces debate over rising welfare costs, particularly among young people claiming sickness benefits for mental health conditions. Mental or neurodevelopmental disorders account for 80% of these claims, prompting politicians to question overdiagnosis. The Royal College of Psychiatrists argues for increased funding, claiming a mental illness pandemic affecting one in eight people requires medical treatment to prevent benefit dependency. However, evidence suggests psychiatric treatments produce only modest short-term symptom reductions on measurement scales, with no demonstrated translation to improved real-world outcomes or long-term employment benefits. Historical welfare analysis indicates financial support can be provided without medical labeling.

Read at Psychology Today