Evaluating the Blue Jays' bullpen early in the campaign

"Jeff Hoffman has struggled to start the season, blowing three saves in six attempts and posting a 7.59 ERA in 12 appearances, prompting a change in the closer role."

"The Blue Jays' bullpen has pitched for at least two-thirds of the game in six instances, highlighting the strain on relievers due to injuries in the starting rotation."

"Hoffman was fourth in the league with 33 saves in 2025 but also led in home runs given up in the ninth inning, raising questions about his reliability."

"Despite Hoffman's past postseason success, including striking out 18 batters, his performance in critical moments has led to a reevaluation of his role as closer."

The Toronto Blue Jays' bullpen has been heavily utilized in 2026 due to injuries in the starting rotation, pitching nearly half the team's innings. With starters not going deep into games, the bullpen has faced significant pressure. Jeff Hoffman, the team's closer, has been replaced by a closer by committee after a poor start to the season, including three blown saves and a 7.59 ERA. Despite past success, Hoffman's performance has raised concerns about his effectiveness in high-pressure situations.

Read at BlueJaysNation