Congress Could Raise Social Security's $184,500 Tax Cap Without Cutting Benefits

"The Benefit Formula That Determines Your Monthly Check Social Security doesn't simply pay everyone the same amount in retirement. Instead, the program uses your 35 highest-earning years to calculate an average, then applies a progressive formula through "bend points"-income thresholds where the replacement rate changes. This progressive structure means lower earners receive proportionally more generous benefits relative to their contributions, creating a safety net that provides stronger support where it's needed most while still rewarding higher lifetime earnings."

"Congress can adjust these percentages without cutting anyone's existing benefit. Lawmakers could modify the replacement rates for future beneficiaries while leaving current retirees untouched. The adjustment affects how future benefits grow, not what you're already receiving, representing a change in the formula rather than a direct cut to promised benefits."

"Raising the Payroll Tax Cap Social Security has always had an earnings ceiling for taxation. In 2026, that cap sits at $184,500, creating a situation where ultra-high earners contribute the same total amount as upper-middle-class professionals. This ceiling limits the program's revenue base and represents one of the most straightforward levers Congress could pull to strengthen Social Security's finances. This change would strengthen the program's finances by expanding the tax base to include more high-income earnings."

Social Security benefits derive from an individual's 35 highest-earning years and apply a progressive replacement formula with "bend points" that favor lower earners proportionally. Lawmakers can change replacement percentages for future beneficiaries while leaving current retirees' checks intact, affecting benefit growth rather than already promised payments. The payroll tax currently excludes earnings above a cap—$184,500 in 2026—shrinking the revenue base. Raising or removing that cap would expand payroll-tax revenue by capturing high-income earnings. Combined formula adjustments and tax-base expansion can strengthen long-term program finances without immediate cuts to current monthly benefits.

Read at 24/7 Wall St.