Study Explores AI-Written Admissions Essays
Briefly

Study Explores AI-Written Admissions Essays
"The study analyzed tens of thousands of essays submitted to an unnamed selective institution over four years, starting before the introduction of generative AI tools. The researchers found that lower-income students-represented in this study by those who received an application fee waiver-were more likely to use AI in their essays, as were students who were ultimately rejected from the college."
"Even among the cohort of students who had used AI, lower-income students were more likely to be rejected than higher-income students, the researchers found. This may be because higher-income students can afford better versions of AI tools and might be working with counselors or essay coaches who understand how to use AI most effectively, she said."
""High-income students have a lot of different resources; they have counselors, they have teachers, they have more support on top of ChatGPT," Lee said. On the other hand, lower-income students "might only be able to use the free tier instead of the $200-per-month [version of] Claude, and the quality of the outcome of what free-tier ChatGPT gives us is really poor.""
Admissions offices have faced AI-generated essays for more than three and a half years. A 2024 survey found about half of applicants use AI to brainstorm and one in five use it to create a first draft. A study analyzed tens of thousands of essays submitted to a selective institution over four years, including periods before generative AI tools. The study found that applicants who received application fee waivers, representing lower-income students, were more likely to use AI. Students who were ultimately rejected were also more likely to use AI. Among AI users, lower-income students were more likely to be rejected than higher-income students, potentially because higher-income students can access better AI tools and additional support such as counselors or essay coaches.
[
|
]