James Burrows on 'The Comeback' and Hollywood's AI Problem: 'I Have No Idea What the F**k Happened'

"“Good, but never gonna be great,” Jimmy says. “The machine is fast and cooperative, I'll give it that. But I saw every one of those jokes coming, and so did you. Surprising only comes from a group of writers, huddled in a corner, beating themselves up to beat out a better joke. It's the chubby guy who's a secret alcoholic. It's the gay guy who, despite all the work he's done, still hates himself a little. Or the funny woman who's been invisible for way too long. They turn all that pain into a joke. Val, those broken, beautiful souls are what make something great. And you didn't see it coming.”"

"His words, written by Kudrow and Michael Patrick King, are delivered with a frankness born from unsurpassed experience; experience “ The Comeback” has relied upon for three seasons across three decades to deliver the truth to Valerie and viewers alike. After all, Jimmy the Director, as Burrows refers to his character in the HBO comedy, conveys an outsized authority - for Valerie as well as the audience watching at home - thanks primarily to the non-actor playing the part."

"A paragon of television, listing Burrows' accolades - co-creator of “Cheers,” director of “Friends,” “Will & Grace,” and “The Mary Tyler Moore Show,” 11 Emmy wins and 47 nominations - doesn't begin to relate his impact on the TV industry and culture at large. Simply seeing his name in the credits elevates the creative potential of the series lucky enough to snag him."

"So when Jimmy the Director makes a statement in “The Comeback,” it matters that much more because Burrows is saying it, too. “What Michael said is what I believe"

Jimmy the Director ends work on Valerie Cherish’s show after the pilot succeeds but remains only “OK.” He criticizes AI-written comedy for being fast and cooperative while producing jokes that are easy to anticipate. He contrasts predictable setups with the surprise created by human writers who push themselves to craft better material. He describes recurring sitcom character archetypes—secret alcoholism, self-hatred, and long-invisible funny women—as sources of pain transformed into humor. He argues that those broken, beautiful souls create greatness and that Valerie failed to see that element. The authority of Jimmy’s message is reinforced by the real-world television experience associated with the character’s portrayal.

Read at IndieWire