Here's How Food Network Chooses Its Mystery Chopped Baskets - Tasting Table

"While it's not really spoken about on the show, there has been a small bit of information revealed online about the people who assemble the baskets. It turns out that the ingredients are chosen by the culinary producer of the show and the executive chef of the Food Network, who was Ginevra Iverson at the time of writing."

"According to the Food Network, the pair come up with ingredient ideas and then sit down together to figure out some possible combinations, all while checking a list of everything that's been used on the show previously to avoid repetition. There aren't really any rules, but the team does test how long it takes them to come up with a solution to the proposed basket. If it's longer than 15 seconds, they toss the idea out."

"There are three rounds on Chopped and the contestants are given one basket for each, typically to create an appetizer, main, and dessert. Each basket has four items that all need to be used. One substantial ingredient, like a starch or protein, is usually included for the main course, and there always has to be one ingredient that's slightly left field, like the pig lips."

Chopped has challenged top chefs with mystery baskets for nearly two decades. The show's premise centers on transforming obscure and interesting ingredients into high-quality dishes within 20 to 30 minutes. The baskets are created by the Food Network's culinary producer and executive chef, who brainstorm ingredient combinations while consulting a database of previously used items to prevent repetition. The team tests each basket combination, discarding ideas that take longer than 15 seconds to solve. Three rounds feature baskets with four ingredients each, typically for appetizer, main, and dessert courses. Each basket includes a substantial ingredient and one unconventional item to increase difficulty.

Read at Tasting Table